Competitive Analysis of Trader Joe’s Competitors: Wegman’s, The Fresh Market, Whole Foods

Jan 6

13 min read

This competitive analytics report was performed for Emerson College's MK673-03 course Analytics for Impact.

Competitive Analysis (Trader Joe’s)

MK 673: Analytics for Impact

March 28, 2024

INTRODUCTION

Competitive analyses gather information on various competing companies' products, sales, and marketing strategies to discover opportunities, strengths, and weaknesses in a marketing strategy. Our competitive analysis focuses on Trader Joe’s and its key competitors Wegman’s, The Fresh Market, and Whole Foods. Trader Joe’s, one of the oldest grocery store chains in the United States, has a strong customer base who love it due to its affordability, unique products, healthy food, and its atmosphere. This report explores data on Trader Joe’s and each key competitor to assess the most advantageous marketing strategies and tactics using the PESTLE, Porter, and SWOT analyses to form attack strategies and recommendations.

PESTLE ANALYSIS

The PESTLE Analysis is crucial to a competitive analysis because it analyzes the outside factors that can affect how a company performs. In the grocery store industry, many factors are an overarching theme across Trader Joe’s and its competitors. Several factors recur throughout each of the competitor’s PESTLE Analysis, including taxes, employment, minimum wage, supply chain costs and management, inflation, political stability, online platforms, and sustainability initiatives.

Some of these overarching political factors fall in line with the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act that oversees that industry. It also falls in line with the FDA, which oversees company compliance with regulations. The FDA investigates companies and products to ensure compliance. If they do not, it is a very expensive fine or penalty. It requires substantial money to conform to these regulations. Another factor is the employment law and minimum wage, which, hourly at least, varies by state. The U.S. federal mandated minimum wage is $7.25 as of January 2023. States with a high cost of living can have a higher hourly minimum wage, like Massachusetts, whose minimum wage is at $15. Economically, labor costs are increasing, and this can encroach on profitability. A rise in prices for petroleum products or gasoline could disrupt the supply chain domestically and internationally, causing prices to rise and inflation to become an even greater problem. Legally, tax laws could change and affect profits, as well food quality or product recalls can result in lawsuits or worse.

Trader Joe’s

The large majority of shoppers at Trader Joe’s are politically left-leaning. This indicates that they are more likely to shop at stores that also indicate a similar political leaning. At the very least, it’s critical for Trader Joe’s not to lean right politically to remain in line with its consumers. Technologically, Trader Joe’s can expand on its first podcast series, recipes, blogs, and contests to provide events and webinars to foster a greater online community and presence within their target audience. Legally, Trader Joe’s must be diligent in complying with regulations, as it will result in Trader Joe’s needing to spend an alarming amount of money to remedy the issue. Socially, I recommend emphasizing the younger demographics more and reaching them via social media. It will be more effective. And, if Trader Joe’s promotes a high emphasis on climate change and sustainability initiatives on social media, their young audience will be even more loyal.

Wegman’s

Wegman’s provides several technological advantages. It has an online pharmacy service, grocery ordering online for pickup or delivery, cake ordering, as well as providing wine recommendations, recipes, and meal options. However, Wegman’s could also expand their online retail presence. While Trader Joe’s is not as heavily leaning towards retail as Wegman’s, this still provides key insights Trader Joe’s could mimic, like wine recommendations. Wegman’s is also subject to regulations governing the sale of alcohol and tobacco, working condition requirements, and public accessibility requirements. However, Wegman’s is privately held and it’s a disadvantage. It has limited layers of management and decisions are usually made by select members of the company. This could be a detriment since that is a very narrow scope of view.

The Fresh Market

Similar to Trader Joe’s and Wegman’s, The Fresh Market’s political and legal factors remain similar. However, The Fresh Market is a part of its parent company, Cencosud, which is a major multi-brand retail conglomerate in Latin America. This parent company could affect taxes, profitability, and supply chain distributions. It benefits from Cencosud for its expertise in research, development, and technology. Its high-quality products mean The Fresh Market has higher prices too. Consumers of The Fresh Market are quite concerned with carbon footprint, ethical sourcing, and sustainability. Some social identifiers in The Fresh Market’s consumers include a hectic lifestyle, an increasing demand for sugar-free products, a preference for organic and naturally baked goods, a growing economy, increasing urbanization, changing eating patterns, and a growing young population.

Whole Foods Market

What is different about Whole Foods compared to Trader Joe’s and its other competitors is that Whole Foods was acquired by Amazon. This likely affected its taxes and profitability when acquired. However, this also comes with many benefits and creates a formidable competitor. Whole Foods is integrated with Amazon’s e-commerce platform, which offers opportunities for Whole Foods to reach a broader target audience, expand its online presence, and do so even during economic downturns. Socially, Amazon’s customer-centric strategy and strong brand reputation also help Whole Foods gain new customers and expand into new target segments. Amazon Prime members can also use the Whole Foods app to get in-person discounts, get pickups and deliveries, and get Amazon packages at lockers in Whole Foods. Amazon’s legal resources and support can help comply with regulations and support sustainability initiatives like ethical sourcing. Lastly, Amazon's commitment to sustainability and renewable energy is likely to influence Whole Foods' sustainability effort.

PORTER ANALYSIS

Applying Porter's Five Forces model to the competitive analysis provides a comprehensive understanding of the grocery industry.

1. Threat of New Entrants

The pandemic fueled peak grocery demand as consumers cooked most of their meals at home. Looking ahead, the forecast is optimistic mainly as consumers continue to prioritize healthy, fresh foods and home-cooked meals (Mintel, 2023).

High growth expectations may attract new competitors. Also, Trader Joe's faces a high threat of new entrants due to low capital requirements and entry barriers, allowing potential competitors to enter the market relatively easily.

2. Threat of Substitutes

The threat of substitutes in the grocery industry is high, as food is readily available from alternative sources like restaurants and food trucks. Low customer loyalty and switching costs exacerbate this threat, making it easier for customers to opt for alternatives.

Moreover, consumer shopping behaviors, including increased preference for private labels and the growth of online shopping, may influence loyalty to major brands like Trader Joe’s. (Mintel, 2023).

3. Bargaining Power of Customers:

Consumers are increasingly sensitive to food prices after months of record-high inflation. More than three-quarters of consumers feel that grocers could do more to lower food prices, and consumers are voicing their frustrations with rising costs. In response to high prices, many consumers have abandoned their usual retailers to seek lower prices from mass merchandisers and discounters. (Mintel, 2023).

This is because the bargaining power of customers is high in the grocery retail chain sector, primarily due to the abundance of alternatives and low switching costs.

4. Bargaining Power of Suppliers

The bargaining power of suppliers is low for Trader Joe's, attributed to the presence of numerous suppliers and the lack of differentiated supplies. This enables Trader Joe's to switch between suppliers easily, reducing costs and weakening the suppliers' bargaining power.

However, the impact of food inflation on grocery budgets may affect the bargaining power of suppliers. Private labels have been and will continue to be a bright spot, allowing retailers to recapture shopper loyalty through quality store brand innovation. (Mintel, 2023).

5. Competitive Rivalry

The competitive rivalry in the grocery industry is intense, with Trader Joe's facing competition from major players like Whole Foods Market, Wegman’s, Fresh Market, and increasing private labels.

The growth of e-commerce and the normalization of multi-channel shopping have impacted brands like Trader Joe's, which primarily rely on physical store sales.

SWOT ANALYSIS

Each of the establishments that were chosen for this paper holds a blend of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. A comprehensive SWOT analysis of the key competitors (Wegmans, Fresh Market, and Whole Foods) shows the areas where each grocery store chain is strong, where it is weak, where there is an opportunity for growth, and the threats in the current situation or near future. This analysis is synthesized in the Appedix’s Exhibit 1, tables 1 through 4.

Wegmans is known for its commitment to affordability and its vibrant work culture; the establishment was ranked 3rd best company to work for by Fortune 100 in 2022 (Wegmans, 2024). It also launched a successful healthy food line called “Foods You Feel Good About.” Moreover, the Wegmans locations offer services such as florist, catering, gift ideas, recipes, and shopping lists for its customers. However, Wegmans grapples with a limited product range and regional confinement, impeding broader market penetration. The absence of public trading dampens its visibility, despite its strengths. An opportunity for Wegmans is to provide customers with a selection of healthy frozen food. This would stay on brand and would be a highly desired product from the target market. The stores could also create sections of the store dedicated to specific client lifestyles, such as a vegan area, a gluten-free section, an organic section, and many others. It could also create a system that provides easy order and delivery for online shopping.

The second competitor, Fresh Market, exudes a timeless charm. With over 30 years in the market, the food chain has a strong credibility. There are over 130 Fresh Market locations throughout all of the US. They all have a unique ambiance characterized by classical music, rustic decorations, and the warmth of the employees. Fresh Market also has popular programs such as Meal Idea, Holiday Idea, and Seafood Tips, which give ideas and tips for shopping. The weaknesses are a lack of selection and turnover of products over long periods and the fact that there are no services outside of grocery shopping given in Fresh Market locations. The establishment has the potential to become a prominent global brand and provide products such as clothes, sanitary, household, and others. The rising cost of raw materials and government regulations pose a threat to Fresh Market.

Whole Foods has strong brand recognition and reputation (it ranked 3rd on the Reputation Institute’s survey of most trusted retail companies in 2015). It also has and enforces high-quality standards for all the products it carries. One of the major weaknesses is that Whole Foods is almost entirely dependent on the American markets (97% of revenues come from the US market). Relying on a single market can make a company highly subjected to unpredictable changes. Consumers also often perceive Whole Foods as overpriced. To tackle this issue, Whole Foods has launched 365, offering affordable healthy food. Another opportunity is that having a strong brand image and perception makes collaborations with other companies easy and natural. The threats that Whole Foods is facing are bad publicity (specifically the one resulting from the accusations of overcharging its consumers) and increasing competition in such a saturated field.

Trader Joe’s is a company its recurring clientele loves because of its transparency and low cost. The grocery store chain has 530 stores in 42 states and is one of the oldest in the country (founded in 1967). It maintains a strong relationship with its key suppliers. Trader Joe's has suffered from product recalls in the past, which hurt the perception and brand image. It also does not deliver food. Its main market is in the United States, but it is slowly expanding in Europe; targeting the EU represents a great opportunity for the food chain. One of the biggest threats is the exceptionally high turnover rate of employees: because Trader Joe’s fails to maintain loyal employees, resources are wasted on continuous training.

ATTACKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Wegmans:

Attack Strategies: Wegmans, known for its extensive product range and one-stop shopping convenience, could attract customers by expanding its offerings even further. Enhancing customer service and engagement could also solidify its appeal.

Trader Joe's Response: To counteract Wegmans, Trader Joe's should focus on its unique product development, ensuring a continuous stream of distinctive offerings. Additionally, elevating the in-store experience with interactive and immersive elements could make shopping at Trader Joe's more engaging and enjoyable.

The Fresh Market:

Attack Strategies: The Fresh Market can capitalize on its reputation for high-quality, specialty, and fresh products by emphasizing these aspects even more. Enhancing the store's atmosphere and design could elevate the shopping experience to feel more premium.

Trader Joe's Response: Trader Joe's should underscore its value proposition, emphasizing the exceptional quality and affordability of its products. Boosting brand loyalty through customer loyalty programs and community involvement can also deepen customer connections.

Whole Foods Market:

Attack Strategies: Whole Foods might expand its organic and natural product lines, catering to health- and sustainability-conscious consumers. By advancing its sustainability initiatives and community involvement, Whole Foods can attract socially conscious shoppers.

Trader Joe's Response: Trader Joe's should highlight its exclusive and innovative product offerings, especially those focusing on sustainability and health. Strengthening community ties and delivering outstanding customer service can enhance customer relations and loyalty.

In summary, Trader Joe's can sustain its competitive edge by continually innovating its product lineup, enhancing the shopping experience, reinforcing its value proposition, and fostering stronger community and customer relationships. These strategies, tailored to counteract the strengths of its competitors, will enable Trader Joe's to maintain its unique position in the grocery market landscape.

Appendix:

Exhibit 1: SWOT Analysis in Tables 1-4

Table 1 - Trader Joe’s

Strengths Transparency Low Cost Fast growth Big network One of the oldest in the US Strong relationships with suppliers	Weaknesses Product recalls Heavily relies on US market Does not deliver food
Opportunities Expansion in EU countries Expanding organic and non-GMO product selection	Threats High employee turnover

Table 2 - Whole Foods

Strengths Strong brand recognition and reputation High-quality standards	Weaknesses Only relies on the American market Perceived overpricing Allegations of overcharging
Opportunities 365 by Whole Foods Expansion in the global market Collaborations	Threats Not recovering from bad publicity Increasing competition pressure

Table 3 - Wegmans

Strengths Low price Good work culture “Foods you feel good about” Florist, catering, gift ideas, recipes, and shopping list services Efficient mobile app	Weaknesses Limited range of products Not publicly traded Only present in the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States
Opportunities Providing a healthy frozen food line Widen product range Provide dedicated sections for vegans, gluten-free, organic food, etc. Provide a delivery system for online shopping	Threats Rising competition Rising food production costs

Table 4 - Fresh Market

Strengths Credibility Distributed network Unique ambiance Ideas and tips for shopping Online purchasing available	Weaknesses No change in selection over long periods Low market share No services are offered other than grocery
Opportunities Can become a global brand Can provide products outside of grocery such as clothes, sanitary, household etc.	Threats The rising cost of materials Government regulations and unexpected issues resulting from fast growth and expansion

Exhibit 2: PESTLE Analysis, Tables 1-4

Table 1 Trader Joes

Political	Economical	Social
The majority of shoppers are left-leaning Must follow strict rules, regulations, and specifications on its products in its domestic and export markets Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act oversees the food, drug and cosmetics industry FDA oversees compliance with act-related regulations The FDA can conduct investigations, examine products, and regulate products worth $1 trillion per year and ensure that all drugs, biological products, medical devices, animal drugs, feed, and all food comply with regulations. needs to spend substantial money to conform to the regulations. Non-compliance could result in fines and penalties, which increase operating costs.	Labor costs in the US are increasing Increasing the minimum wage could affect the profit margin Increase in labor costs due to: tight labor markets, government-mandated increase in minimum wages, and a higher proportion of full-time employees result Jan. ‘23: minimum wage was $7.25, but hourly wages vary by state, and many states have a higher hourly wage minimum Supply chain factors: price of gas, etc. Inflation	Demographics like Gen Z and Millenials (primarily Gen Z) posts blogs on product knowledge, trend statements, and fashion holds website promotions and contests to attract teen customers
Technological	Legal	Environmental
24% of Trader Joe’s shoppers are innovators or early adopters of new products 2018: launched its first-ever podcast series offers a diverse range of recipes to end users through its website	10 company deals since 2011 (venture financing, private equity, acquisition, asset transaction) FDA and compliance with the Act and regulations relating to food, drugs, and cosmetics Tax laws could affect taxes, therefore its profit	A high share of Trader Joe’s shoppers think that climate change is an issue that needs to be addressed limited store locations is aligned with its unique business approach but could be a weakness in its operational model Not super transparent on its product sourcing and such

Table 2 Wegman’s

Political	Economical	Social
Similar to Trader Joe’s, must follow the FDA and that Act’s guidelines on food, drugs, and cosmetics Political stability which can affect regulations	Inflation and supply chain factors International distribution, economies, partnerships Minimum wage issues	Demographics Lifestyle: family life, etc
Technological	Legal	Environmental
Online pharmacy service Will benefit from expanding its online retail more Grocery pickup/delivery options Order cakes, clip coupons, etc Provides wine recommendations, recipes, and meal options Events posted to the site	Privately owned subject to the extensive federal, state, and local governmental regulations Is subject to regulations governing the sale of alcohol and tobacco, working condition requirements, public accessibility requirements, and others comply with numerous provisions regulating health and sanitation standards, facility inspection, food labeling, and licensing	Carbon footprint/sustainability Ethical sourcing

Table 3 The Fresh Market Inc.

Political	Economical	Social
Similar to Trader Joe’s, must follow the FDA and that Act’s guidelines on food, drugs, and cosmetics Taxes Government regulations Labor costs/laws	Supply chain factors: price of gas, etc. Inflation Minimum wage variations Higher priced items due to quality Global: could expand into the global meat and livestock market Labor costs	Demographics: age, family structure, etc Hectic lifestyle, increasing demand for sugar-free products, and preference for organic and naturally baked goods, along with a growing economy, increasing urbanization, changing eating patterns, and growing young population
Technological	Legal	Environmental
Could expand into agricultural tech innovations that affect alleviate food production issues and sourcing benefits from the parent company in research and development, technological skills	Government regulations - compliance with food safety Employment and intellectual property laws for safe working, wages, etc, and also trademarks, patents 12 company deals Part of: Cencosud (which is one of the largest multi-brand retail conglomerates in Latin America, with operations in Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Peru, and Colombia) Product recalls/food quality issues could lead to legal ramifications Minimum wage issues	Sustainability initiatives and regulations affecting sourcing, packaging, and waste management Consumer attitudes and carbon footprint

Table 4 Whole Foods

Political	Economical	Social
Similar to Trader Joe’s, must follow the FDA and that Act’s guidelines on food, drugs, and cosmetics Taxes Government regulations Labor costs/laws Amazon's influence on government policies and regulations Amazon’s acquisition of it	Inflation Minimum wage variations Purchasing power enhanced by Amazon’s financial resources Integrated with Amazon's e-commerce platform it offers opportunities for Whole Foods to reach a broader customer base and expand its presence online, especially during economic downturns when consumers may prioritize convenience and price	Demographics: age, family structure, etc Amazon's brand reputation and customer-centric approach: gain new customers, expand target segments Amazon’s data analytics expertise can help personalize customer preferences
Technological	Legal	Environmental
operating an online grocery business and finding micro-segments accordingly (is a crucial element of a successful strategy) (amazon) Integrated with Amazon tech Prime member Whole Foods app in-person discount, delivery, pick up option available too Amazon lockers	Subsidiary of amazon 22 company deals Government regulations - compliance with food safety employment/minimum wage Amazon’s legal resources/backing can help in complying with regulations and such	Carbon footprint/sustainability Amazon's commitment to sustainability and renewable energy initiatives may influence Whole Foods' sustainability efforts

Work Cited

Steiger, B. (2023). Grocery Retailing: In-store and Online - US – 2023. https://reports-mintel-com.proxy.emerson.edu/display/1155683/ (accessed March 26, 2024).

Trader Joe's Company. Fort Mill: Mergent, 2024. ProQuest. Web. 26 Mar. 2024.

Wegmans Food Markets, Inc. Fort Mill: Mergent, 2024. ProQuest. Web. 26 Mar. 2024.

Wegmans. [Press releases]. 26 Mar. 2024. https://www.wegmans.com/news-media/press-releases/fortune-media-and-great-place-to-work-name-wegmans-to-2023-fortune-100-best-companies-to-work-for/ Shibboleth Authentication Request, advantage-marketline-com.proxy.emerson.edu/Company/Profile/trader-joes-company?swot. Accessed 26 Mar. 2024.

Shibboleth Authentication Request, advantage-marketline-com.proxy.emerson.edu/Company/Summary/wegmans_food_markets_inc. Accessed 26 Mar. 2024.

The Fresh Market Inc. Fort Mill: Mergent, 2024. ProQuest. Web. 26 Mar. 2024.

Shibboleth Authentication Request, advantage-marketline-com.proxy.emerson.edu/Company/Profile/the-fresh-market-inc?swot. Accessed 26 Mar. 2024.

Shibboleth Authentication Request, advantage-marketline-com.proxy.emerson.edu/Company/CompanyDeals/whole_foods_market_inc. Accessed 26 Mar. 2024.

Spearman, Jack, et al. Statista Consumer Insights, Statista Consumer Insights, Feb. 2024, file:///Users/rachelliacos/Downloads/study_id65611_grocery-stores-trader-joe-s-shoppers-in-the-united-states.pdf.

“What Is a Competitive Analysis & How to Do It (with Template).” Semrush Blog, www.semrush.com/blog/competitive-analysis/. Accessed 27 Mar. 2024.